Texte paru dans: / Appeared in:
Fanfare Magazine: 10:1 (09-10/1986) 
Pour s'abonner / Subscription information
Les abonnés à Fanfare Magazine ont accès aux archives du magazine sur internet.
Subscribers to Fanfare Magazine have access to the archives of the magazine on the net.

Alia Vox

Code-barres / Barcode : 8435408099448

Reviewer: Edward Strickland

François le Grand (he never gave 'em a chance to call him le neveu de Couperin, adolescent prodigy that he was) is the greatest composer produced by France (Rameauvians, Romantics, and Impressionists can send their rebuttals—no letter-bombs, please—c/o the Editor), and the Apothéoses may be the greatest of his secular creations, surpassing even the harpsichord works. Hesperion XX had already produced, in their recording of Les Nations, what may be the most impressive single offering in the French Baroque chamber-music discography. So I approached this disc with carefully controlled euphoria.

I was not disappointed. The sonics are superior, as often with Astrée; here the guiding spirit is Michel Bernard, who has done so much excellent work for French Harmonia Mundi. In terms of musical direction, Jordi Savall is not listed as leader of the consort, for the first time in my experience. This may be due to the prominence of the violins in these works rather than the gambas which have been featured in earlier recordings. In any case, the ensemble seems as mellifluous and impassioned as usual, though I think the violinists tend to release a bit prematurely in spots. The group, by the way, is rather strikingly international in composition, including representatives of Spain, England, Italy, the Netherlands, the United States, and France.


The American is Hopkinson Smith, a lutenist-guitarist-theorbist I have praised in the past. His presence in the continuo adds a marvelous sense of plaintiveness and warmth to the accounts. Once again, as in their Nations, the ensemble manages to sound larger than the sum of its parts—this time without winds, a rather unusual accomplishment. As a result, the mood-changes of the works are delineated with greater forcefulness than in the exquisite Kuijkens performance on Pro Arte (which made my Want List some years back): there is simply more drama here—not more delicacy perhaps, but the delicacy there appears all the more affectingly in juxtaposition with the more energetic sections that often frame it. In the Corelli Apothéose, indeed, that framing is the norm, for the work is largely an adaptation of the slow-fast alternation of movements in the sonata da chisa. The Lully Apothéose is a more ambitious (and longer) work, written a year after the 1724 Corelli tribute, rather didactic—though charmingly so—in its tendentious programming of the union of French and Italian styles. Couperin was the chief promoter of that High-Baroque “fusion“ music, and the conclusion of the Lully Apothéose is his most tersely eloquent argument.

The notes by Philippe Beaussant are characteristically insightful and provocative, though I think he overstates the ironic element in the later work, mistaking conventional grandiloquence for satire in both Couperin's dedication and in the first section of the piece.

This is a superb disc. Not the type I expect to wear out but to turn to rarely and at the proper moment. It may say something about the disc (as well as the French Baroque and the reviewer) to note that I cannot listen to this record in daytime or with the lights on.



Sélectionnez votre pays et votre devise en accédant
à Presto Classical
(Bouton en haut à gauche)

Livraison mondiale


Choose your country and currency when reaching
Presto Classical
(Upper left corner)

Worldwide delivery


Cliquez l'un ou l'autre bouton pour découvrir bien d'autres critiques de CD
 Click either button for many other reviews